By Bryan Lemanski and Emily Dentinger
No, it does not actually exist.
This was a humbling revelation for sports fans and lay people everywhere, as the veil of intrigue was pulled back on the notorious yellow line. For those of us that discovered this reality (embarrassingly) late in life, the shock is still setting in.
Regardless of whether you fell for this deception or not, the mechanics and technology underlying the NFL’s ability to flawlessly—and very realistically—paint a virtual yellow line onto a football field is a black box for most. So how exactly does it work?
What is it?
The virtual yellow line that appears on your television screen during a football game denotes where on the field the offense needs to get the ball to reset their downs. It’s the ‘first-down’ line. The line has existed in NFL productions since 1998 and has remained a fan-favorite staple; the thought of watching a football game at home without the yellow-line horrifies most viewers.
Who created it?
The yellow line is an engineering feat attributed to Sportvision, Inc (subsequently acquired by SMT). The concept of virtually-enhanced sports viewing was initially directed toward the NHL, when Sportvision created a system to “highlight” the puck during a game to enhance visibility for at-home viewers. Although ‘glow puck’ failed to win over audiences, Sportvision applied a similar technology to football in subsequent years.
How does it work?
Prior to each NFL game, producers create a 3D mesh rendering of the field. Multiple cameras are used to capture hundreds of images from various perspectives and angles of the field. The cameras identify key markings on the fields – such as painted-on logos, yard lines, and sidelines – and establish a “color key” of the turf or grass. The cameras capture and record the specific shades of green on the field, which are then calibrated to account for sunlight, shade, rain, and the Green Bay Packers’ jerseys. Any painted-on logos, advertisements, or field features are also accounted for.
Once the 3D rendering and color compilation is complete, a production team will project a pixelated yellow line over the 3D mesh throughout the game. By imposing the virtual line over the 3D mesh, producers create the very realistic effect of perspective, regardless of camera angle. The color calibration ensures that any obstruction to the yellow line (e.g., a player or the ball) appears in the foreground, which gives the effect of a painted-on line.
Once calibrated, the system will process camera feeds in real time during the game.
Cameras are everywhere in modern sportscasting: on the sidelines, in drones, embedded in endzone markers. The yellow line needs to look like it’s painted onto the field, so the perspective and angle of the rendering need to seamlessly respond to frequent and instantaneous camera angle changes. Pan, tilt, and zoom of each camera is accounted for during a broadcast. The 3D mesh rendering allows the production team to pixelate the yellow line in a manner that precisely responds to these camera variations.
In sum: the yellow line is wildly more complicated than simply hand-drawing a line across the TV screen.
Did patents save the yellow line?
That might be a slight exaggeration. But just slight.
As with most technological innovation, the yellow line required years of ideation, engineering, and iteration. Preempting the market demand and time needed for refinement, Sportvision patented multiple aspects of their technology across a number of different patents to protect from infringement and copycats. The Sportvision patent portfolio protects the novel color-blurring technology (US 6,229,550), image insertion in video streams (US 6,100,925), methods for enhancing live broadcasts (US 5,917,553), and more.
Although the yellow line would certainly still exist without patent protection, the quality of the technology and the incentive to innovate would suffer. Sportvision leveraged legal property rights to carve out their exclusive rights, resulting in the time and space to innovate and a competitive advantage in the marketplace.
What is your “Yellow Line”?
Your ideas and innovation are important. Stay on top of legal protection with a robust patent strategy. Contact our team to get started today!
